The 51 year Lesson Plan

It takes a lifetime to plan, not five minutes. Wherever you plan your lesson, whether it’s in your head, on paper, or online, a lesson plan is a struggle, a labour of love, hate, and compromise. It is open to constant revision, it is a dialogue with the past, present and future and will always take longer than the writing of a few words.

An example:

In a school in which I taught the head of D&T was told off for having the following written in his planner:

‘Dovetail Joint’

Apparently as a lesson plan it was not detailed enough, it didn’t include differentiation, it didn’t include assessment, it didn’t include levels and he, a very experienced teacher was told he had not put enough thought into his planning.

Pardon my French but Couilles!

He’d been teaching kids to do dovetail joints for years, he knew better than any detailed written lesson plan would ever recognise! This is the sort of silly bureaucracy that wastes so much energy and stresses out experienced staff needlessly.

Then someone pointed out that dovetail joints are unnecessary in the twenty first century and he should be teaching ‘how to use a staple gun’ or how to read Ikea instructions, brandish allen keys and a screwdriver. I pointed out we always need Classics and craft and the dovetail joint is a sign of beauty and care that connects us to our past and to quality.

A bit like an old teacher.

18 responses to “The 51 year Lesson Plan”

  1. Brilliant story.
    Says it all!

    Like

  2. Sometimes it is a real struggle to get fellow members of SMT to understand that planning is a reflection of teaching and learning, not the other way round. Funny thing is,, when I asked senior teachers in my school to redesign the lesson planning format (I gave them a blank slate), they created the same format, just in a different arrangement. It was one of those ‘ah ha’ moments when I realised we needed not to break changes but break down walls. So we did, and continue to do so.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I’d be interested to hear how you are ‘breaking down walls’

      Like

  3. I bet we could replicate that story across hundreds of schools in the UK. Sometimes it feels as though the last 30 years of my teaching life haven’t existed! Young SLT think they have invented everything … Active learning 1986 … Bring back ‘Fresh Oven Pies’!

    Like

  4. Great little story! Indeed. A lesson cannot be planned in 5 minutes!

    Like

    1. Ha! Yes, yes indeed. Thank you 🙂

      Liked by 2 people

  5. […] Companion post: 51 Year Lesson Plan […]

    Like

  6. Really excellent post – my Dad was a D&T teacher – forwarding this on to him as it will find a lot of resonance with the reasons he left the profession

    Like

    1. Ah…

      Give him my best wishes.

      Like

      1. He is now merrily rebuilding another house in France – but thank-you I will do

        Like

  7. […] excellent blog post about the importance of subject knowledge and experience in teaching https://martinrobborobinson.wordpress.com/2014/02/04/the-51-year-lesson-plan/ led me to reflect on how student teachers learn to plan effective lessons. This is an issue that […]

    Like

  8. […] A crude drive for consistency – often in the form of checklists or non-negotiables – can reduce opportunities for staff to think intelligently and prevent professional growth. Consistency for the sake of consistency is not the answer. Of course, minimum expectations in a school are required, usually to do with behaviour and safeguarding; but in a profession such as teaching, where approaches are nuanced depending on the subject or age group which is being taught, the culture must allow for the expertise within the school to be applied with some freedom and sense of professional trust. Without this, managerialism can take over, as Martin Robinson captures brilliantly (and tragically) in the following blog post, entitled ‘The 51-year Lesson Plan’. […]

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a comment